Olivia's is a fun out-of-the-way dining spot if you have a little extra time to navigate out to Old Key West Resort. Service is excellent.
Setting and Atmosphere
Disneyfied Key West: lots of pastels, mosaic-tile floors, potted palms, tropical trees in the center of the room. There is some outside seating, which looks out over the waterway. Tile, wood siding, and no tablecloths add up to a very noisy dining room that's getting a little worn around the edges. Disney Vacation Club member photos decorate the walls - Disney's Old Key West Resort was one of the first DVC resorts, so members consider Olivia's their home kitchen.
At breakfast, eggs with shrimp and conch cakes; banana-bread French toast; and Cuban sandwich with scrambled eggs, ham, Swiss cheese, and pork loin. At lunch, the Key West burger topped with grilled shrimp and pepper-jack cheese. At dinner, prime rib, sustainable fish with black beans and rice, and coconut-encrusted mahimahi.